The Stranglehold of Structured Activities

The Stranglehold of Structured Activities

Next post Previous post

The invite came in and it's for a Saturday.

There's driving involved. There's a start time and an end time somebody else picked. There will be people, arranged in a room, doing an activity that was selected without consulting you, at a house you have never been to, belonging to somebody you have never met.

And the person who sent it is expecting a yes.

That's the part. The assumption that your Saturday belongs to them is so total that saying no requires a reason, while saying yes requires nothing at all.

"It'll be fun"

That's the line. It's always the line.

And they mean it. That's what makes it worse. They genuinely believe the pottery painting at Karen's cousin's house is going to be fun, and they have decided that if you don't feel that, something is wrong with you.

Fun for who. Say it out loud. Fun for who, specifically.

Because the same afternoon that feels like a good time to one person feels like a hostage situation to another, and only one of those reactions gets to exist in public.

The event isn't even the problem

The event is forty minutes. Fine.

The problem is everything bolted to it.

The forty-five minute drive. The parking. The kitchen small talk with somebody's brother-in-law who wants to tell you about his truck. The stretch where you check your phone and it has been eleven minutes. The exit, which takes twenty minutes and requires three separate goodbyes. Then two hours at home afterward doing nothing, because you're wrecked.

That's the actual product. None of it was in the invitation.

Then you decline and it becomes a situation

"Oh, you're not coming? Why?"

There it is. You now owe a deposition.

Say you're busy and you get "busy doing what." Say you're tired and you get "tired from what." There is no answer that ends it except a specific, verifiable, immovable commitment, which means the only clean way out of an invitation is to have scheduled a conflict before the invitation existed.

So the correct strategy is to be permanently pre-booked against events you have not been invited to yet.

Here's what's actually going on

The people who send these cannot be alone.

That's the whole thing. They cannot sit in a house on a Saturday by themselves, so they build an activity, and then they need bodies in the room to make the activity real, and you are a body.

It was never about you. It was never about pottery. It's a person who needs a full room to feel like their life is happening, recruiting off a list.

And the guilt you get for saying no isn't because they'll miss you. It's because a smaller room is a worse room, and you just made the room smaller.

Look at the over-scheduled ones

Somewhere along the line a full calendar became evidence of a good life.

Booked solid means wanted. Means connected. An empty Saturday means something has gone wrong with you.

That's backwards and everybody knows it's backwards. The person with seventeen commitments isn't more loved. They're more obligated, they cannot tell the difference anymore, and they are going to die having never once had a Saturday they actually picked.

An empty Saturday isn't a hole. It's the only unclaimed thing you own.

The four words

"I'm going to skip this one."

That's the entire policy. Not rude. No excuse. No elaboration, because elaboration is negotiation and there is nothing here to negotiate.

Say it once. Say it flat. Do not apologize and do not give a reason, because a reason can be argued with and a preference cannot.

Some of them will take it and move on. Those are your people.

The rest will decide you've wronged them, they'll be weird about it for a while, and then they'll stop inviting you.

Which was the goal.

How to get out of it

  • Say the four words and stop talking. "I'm going to skip this one." Then nothing. Do not fill the silence. The silence is what makes it stick.
  • Never give a reason. A reason can be solved. "I have to work" gets "come after." "I'm tired" gets "just come for an hour." A preference cannot be solved, which is exactly why nobody uses one.
  • Do not counter-offer. Do not say next time. Next time is a promise, they will hold it, and you'll be right back here in three weeks.
  • Answer late. Not rudely late. Just not immediately. An instant no reads as reflex. A no that lands eleven hours later reads as considered, and nobody argues with considered.
  • Be busy in advance. Put something on the calendar for every Saturday for the next two months. It doesn't have to be anything. It has to have a name.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to give a reason?
No.

They asked, though.
They ask everybody. Nobody has to answer.

What if they get offended?
They will.

Then what?
Nothing. That's the part nobody tells you. Nothing happens.

What if it's family?
Then it's family, you're going, and we both know it.

Isn't this antisocial?
It's selective. There's a difference, and the people who can't tell are the ones sending the invitations.

A note on safety

None of this is advice. Number five eventually requires you to explain what "Dave thing" was on your calendar for six consecutive Saturdays. We sell merch. We are not qualified to tell you how to handle your friend group, your in-laws, or the woman who has been planning this since March. Do what you want. You were going to.